#29 - Isak or Gyokeres: Which Swede should spearhead the Arsenal attack?
Arsenal are being heavily linked with a number of forward, and Swedish duo Alexandr Isak and Viktor Gyokeres head up the list.
As Arsenal look to bolster their attacking options in the upcoming transfer window, two names that have surfaced as potential acquisitions are Viktor Gyokeres and Aleksandr Isak.
Both Swedish centre-forwards present intriguing prospects for Mikel Arteta's side, each bringing distinct strengths and caveats that could impact the Gunners' attacking dynamic.
The duo both possess significant height (Gyokeres 6ft 2’ and Isak 6ft 4’) and that alone would provide the team with an alternative, more of a focal point striker.
Viktor Gyokeres, currently with Sporting Lisbon, has carved out a reputation as a durable and reliable striker. At a slightly older age (26 next month) compared to Isak (25 in September), Gyokeres offers experience and a commendable fitness record that could be invaluable for Arsenal, especially during the grueling stretches of the Premier League and European competitions. His ability to stay fit and consistently available for selection is a significant advantage, minimising the potential disruptions caused by injuries which Arsenal has struggled with in the past.
Gyokeres's style of play is characterised by physical robustness and a knack for positioning, making him a potential focal point in Arsenal's attack. His tenure at Sporting Lisbon has polished his skills against high-caliber European defences, suggesting he could adapt quickly to Arsenal's tactical setups. However, the cost to pry him away from Portugal could be substantial, given his proven track record and importance to his current club.
There are also some question marks still as to his ability to play at the very highest level and whether or not he has the technical qualities to integrate into a team like Arsenal.Â
On the other hand, Aleksandr Isak represents a blend of quality and top-flight experience. Already familiar with the demands of the Premier League, Isak has shown flashes of brilliance that hint at a high ceiling if his development continues. His time with Newcastle United has provided him with a firsthand understanding of English football, an invaluable asset that could allow him to hit the ground running at Arsenal.
Unlike Gyokeres, Isak also has experience playing on the flanks and this versatiltiy could prove critical. You could see Isak lining up as a wide forward with Kai Havertz taking the centre forward role in some games.
However, Isak's career has been somewhat marred by injuries, a concern for Arsenal who would need assurances about his long-term availability. Despite this, his talent is undeniable. Isak brings speed, technical skill, and a creative edge that can unlock defences in ways that differ from Gyokeres's more physical approach.
Let’s take a closer look at their stats, though league difficulty must be taken into account, the stats do help highlight styles.
Shooting
Both players rank very highly in all shooting metrics compared to other forwards, but Gyokeres has the edge over Isak here. The strength of league is likely to balance these out to be about even, and interestingly the non-penalty xG is the same, indicating over the long term Isak may be slightly more of a goal threat (given league strength).
Passing and link up
Again league strength and team style need to be taken into account here. Sporting Lisbon averaged 6.4% more possesion per game than Newcastle, enabling Gyokeres to be more involved, but the numbers in this field are fairly even. Where Isak really falls down is in his assist and key pass numbers, an area he’d need to develop.
Duels
With the players closely matched in the first two areas, it is duels where Gyokeres really excels over Isak. Both players are strong in terms of take ons and carries, but Gyokeres is really elite in this aspect.
Isak is also pretty poor in the air considering he’s 6ft 4’, two inches larger than Gyokeres. Given the deep blocks Arsenal regularly face, the 1.94 Gyokeres wins per 90 (at 48% success rate) is appealing.
Cost
Both players are likely to command hefty fees. Gyokeres, being an established player with a robust fitness record, might have a premium attached to his consistency and reliability. Isak, meanwhile, might also draw a significant outlay due to his potential and existing Premier League experience. The exact costs could be influenced by their current contractual situations, market demand, and the negotiating stance of their respective clubs.
Arsenal's decision will likely hinge on their tactical objectives and risk tolerance, considering both the physical demands of their schedule and the tactical fit within Mikel Arteta's system.
There’s risk with both players. Isak, more of a fitness risk and Gyokeres more of a league adaptation risk. In recent years Arsenal have often favoured moving for Premier League proven players, will this again prove critical?
Whichever choice they make, it will significantly shape the team's attacking capabilities in the seasons to come.